Flopsy 4y, Mopsy 2.5y, Cotton-tail 7m
Mar
21

I’ve just started reading Doing It Their Way and the section on John Taylor Gatto (must read more about what he’s written!) has reminded me of how my reasons for wanting to HE our children have evolved.  Initially it was when I read a thread on an online parenting forum about HEing and it really interested me because, more than anything, it sounded fun.  The concept really ‘fitted’ with me, just as the ideas of homebirthing, breastfeeding, bedsharing etc. have ‘fitted’ well with me.  So I chatted to DH about it and he was over the moon!  “I hated school and was dreading sending our children there - I never realised there was an alternative.” he said.  Great!  So I chatted to my mum.  I remember her saying ages ago that she would seriously reconsider sending any of us four to school if she had her time again - and this from a primary school teacher?  How worrying!  Then I vaguely started looking at HE websites etc. and felt very excited about it all.  I had to try not to ‘wish Flopsy’s life away’ by looking forward to when she would be of school age.  When she was nearly two, I decided to join the then MuddlePuddle email list (now known as Early Years HE) and was delighted to discover that I was not the only over-excited parent of a toddler wanting to find support for when official HEing began.  I started reading about HEing, beginning with One-to-One which I really enjoyed reading.  I then read Free Range Education and was introduced to the concept of autonomous education, which sounded a bit wishy-washy to me at the time, but I was willing to learn more about it.  Thanks to the MuddlePuddle email list, I started reading HE blogs…which led me to start my own nearly a year ago now!  I also got the courage to join the local HE group email list - eek!  I was very excited about meeting some real life HEors but also very nervous.  I ended up going along to an informal, but regular meet up at the Mohair Centre and had the time of my life!  Before going, I had sussed out from the email group that there were other mums of very young children living locally who were looking for somewhere to go regularly with their toddlers where they would be accepted for their less-mainstream ideas of parenting so, along with a few other mums who I met that day, one was set up.  It’s now held every two weeks and is very popular and I’ve learnt so much!  Then I read How Children Learn - a present from my very supportive and encouraging mum (I’m so lucky to have parents and parents-in-law who agree with all the things we do with our children!).  I wrote this about it.  My reasons for HEing grew from ‘it will be fun!’ and ‘I want to spend more time with my children than I’d be able to if they went to school’ and ‘I want to continue watching and enjoying them learning’ and even ‘yay!  Can’t wait to get a blackboard ;-)) to ‘goodness me, school can be damaging - I must HE in order to give them the best chance in life!’ and ‘Pants!  Better get rid of that blackboard fantasy quick smart!’.  I’ve always loved watching them learn things, but I love it even more now that I understand the processes going on.  As they grow up, and I read more and more blogs, I find I’m becoming much more aware of the political climate and of how that relates to and effects us as a family.  I’m very alarmed by the governments attempts to control our lives, and those of our children and this is what has informed my latest reason for wanting to HE.  I can now see that school is ideal for governments - what better way to ensure that the next generation grow up believing that you are the be-all-and-end-all and will trust you unquestioningly?  Schooling (not teachers…I’m not talking about teachers; I’m talking about the system) does its best to remove autonomy and free choice from children and, consequently, from the adults they become.  I don’t know how I turned out to be quite so questioning.  Although my mum is, none of my siblings really are.  I guess having children young has helped…?  I think my training to be a breastfeeding counsellor has done a lot.  Undoubtedly my training; my parenting style based on mutal respect; my learning about HEing and particularly about autonomous learning; have all informed and benefitted eachother.  I’ve talked a lot on here about how the books I’ve read on counselling skills and adult learning (both areas I need to understand in order to be a BFC) have said nearly the same thing as those I’ve read on respectful parenting and on autonomous learning.  So it all makes a lot of sense to me.  Then I read things in the course of my training about the wider world and the politics of breastfeeding; about how breastfeeding is damaged and undermined by the cynical and unethical marketing practices of artificial baby milk manufacturers;  How they employ such tactics as ‘we’ll sponsor your maternity unit…make sure there’s a nursery built into it!’ because of course breastfeeding is more likely to fail if babies are taken away from their mothers and kept in a hosptial nursery so more artificial baby milk will be needed and more money will be made by the manufacturers (just one example).  Knowing this has made me more and more questioning about a whole load of things - I guess I’m a bit of a conspiracy theorist at heart!  Why does the government push us to vaccinate our children?  Why do the HVs start interfering the more you try to stay away from them? Why do they want us to birth our babie in hospital? Why, why, why???  So now one of my reasons for HEing is to keep my children away from this state control as long as I can.  I want them to grow up to be autonomous, self-regulating individuals with strong moral values that have been placed there by themselves, not by someone else.  I don’t want them to grow up like so many of the women I meet who believe that artificial baby milk is as good as breastmilk because ‘otherwise the government wouldn’t allow it to be sold’.  I don’t want them to grow up as adults who say ‘but the government say vaccination is safe so it must be!’.  I don’t even want them to grow up to believe that ‘doctor/midwife/health visitor knows best’.  I’ve come from a questioning background, and even I have felt cowed on occassion by the powers that be telling me off.  Well not my children!  I want my children to choose if they want to trust the government/teachers/health care professionals/whatever, and I want them to have an informed choice.  Mum…thanks for bringing me up this way - I love my right to choose and I hope my children love it too!  Now, how do we do it is the next question!



5 Responses to “My journey to HEing so far”
  1. 1
    Deb Says:
    1:05 pm

    Love Love Love this post - couldn’t agree more :-)

  2. 2
    Sarah Says:
    7:44 pm

    Your excitement about allowing your two girls to think for themselves is infectious. Children need no encouragement to think for themselves if they are not discouraged by the people around them. It is so easy to impose our thoughts and ideas onto our children without meaning to. I know you will respect their choices throughout life - I hope other people will do the same.

  3. 3
    Ron Says:
    12:17 am

    JTG: Dumbing us down is really good reading. Given where I was at with HE, I found it really helpful in the sense of having the experience to be able to extrapolate how other behaviour on my part would manifest changes in education, relationships, etc. This is the speech that he gave that he uses to start the book:

    http://www.worldtrans.org/whole/schoolteacher.txt

  4. 4
    playingitbyear Says:
    5:50 pm

    Thanks, Ron. I’ve printed it off to read in full later on, and will definitely be buying Dumbing Us Down at some point in the not-too-distant future :-)

  5. 5
    Stella Says:
    5:45 pm

    Hello, I realise you wrote this post a while back but I am still in a bit of a post-Clara catch up!!
    I just wanted to say that I could have written this myself! I’m glad I’m not the only one who initially wanted to HE because it would be fun! It still will be fun, and that’s often what I tell people when they ask for my reasons, but it’s become so much more than just that. The more blogs and books I read the more I completely believe that home educating is the best thing for my children for so many reasons that I can’t even list them all.

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.